|
Perhaps
one of the most unique doctrines of
Catholicism is that of purgatory.
Purgatory is a place of burning torment and
suffering that follows physical death, but
precedes heaven. According to Catholic
doctrine, the blood of Jesus cleanses us
from original sin – that is, the sin
inherent in humans that occurred via the
fall in the Garden of Eden. Each
individual commits sins on top of the
original sin, for which only the sinner may
atone. This is achieved partly through
penance and adherence to the sacraments
during their lifetime. The remaining
blemishes of sin must be cleansed through
the fires of purgatory, prior to entering
heaven. One can think of it in terms of
twisted halfway house where one must be
sufficiently tortured before being allowed
to matriculate into decent society. The
Catholic Encyclopedia defines purgatory this way:
Purgatory
(Lat., "purgare", to make clean, to
purify) in accordance with Catholic
teaching is a place or condition of
temporal punishment for those who,
departing this life in
God's grace,
are, not entirely free from venial
faults, or have not fully paid the
satisfaction due to their transgressions.
All
sins are not equal before
God, nor dare
anyone assert that the daily faults of
human frailty will be punished with the
same severity that is meted out to
serious violation of
God's law. On
the other hand whosoever comes into
God's presence
must be perfectly pure for in the
strictest sense His "eyes are too pure,
to behold evil" (Hab., i, 13). For
unrepented venial faults for the payment
of temporal punishment due to sin at time
of death, the Church has always taught
the doctrine of purgatory.
The
Catholic Church teaches that faithful
Catholics should pray for their loved ones
who are in purgatory, in order to hasten
their purification and allow them to go on
to Heaven sooner.
The Catholic doctrine
of purgatory supposes the fact that some
die with smaller faults for which there was
no true repentance, and also the fact that
the temporal penalty due to sin is it times
not wholly paid in this life. The proofs
for the Catholic position, both in
Scripture and in Tradition, are bound up
also with the practice of praying for the
dead. For why pray for the dead, if there
be no belief in the power of prayer to
afford solace to those who as yet are
excluded from the sight of
God? So true is
this position that prayers for the dead and
the existence of a place of purgation are
mentioned in conjunction in the oldest
passages of the Fathers, who allege reasons
for succouring departed souls. Those who
have opposed the doctrine of purgatory have
confessed that prayers for the dead would
be an unanswerable argument if the modern
doctrine of a "particular judgment" had
been received in the early ages.
The
“proofs” used by the Catholic Church to
support the doctrine of purgatory come from
Catholic Tradition (the writings of the
Popes and saints) as opposed to Biblical
scripture. This isn’t to say that they
have not attempted to support the doctrine
Biblically. The following passage from the
Catholic Encyclopedia provides what it describes as proof from
the Old Testament of the Bible. However,
this “proof” comes from the Apocrypha. As
stated in another section, the Apocrypha,
or “Deuterocanonical Books” are hotly
contested and are only found in the
Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Bibles.
Most Protestants and
Jews have disregarded the Apocrypha as
scripture, due to numerous chronological
and other errors that cast doubt on divine
inspiration. During the Protestant
reformation, Luther sided with Jerome, the
translator of the Latin Vulgate, in
deciding that the Apocryphal books should
not be considered Scripture. Jerome
gave his support to the Israel/Palestine
Jews who rejected the Apocrypha instead of
the Hellenistic Jews who readily embraced
these books. While the inclusion of
the Apocrypha had been decided at the
Councils of Hippo and Carthage late in the
fourth century, Luther's action caused the
Roman Catholic Church to react by
reaffirming the canonicity of the Apocrypha
at the Council of Trent in 1546. It
is largely based on these books that the
Catholic Church supports their peculiar
doctrines, including the doctrine of
purgatory. The passages
mentioned below are found in the Apocrypha:
The
tradition of the Jews is put forth with
precision and clearness in II Maccabees.
Judas, the
commander of the forces of Israel,
"making a gathering . . . sent twelve
thousand drachmas of silver to Jerusalem
for sacrifice to be offered for the sins
of the dead, thinking well and
religiously concerning the resurrection
(For if he had not hoped that they that
were slain should rise again, it would
have seemed superfluous and vain to pray
for the dead). And because he considered
that they who had fallen asleep with
godliness, had great grace laid up for
them. "It is therefore a holy and
wholesome thought to pray for the dead,
that they may be loosed from sins" (II
Mach., xii, 43-46). At the time of the
Maccabees the leaders of the people of
God had no
hesitation in asserting the efficacy of
prayers offered for the dead, in order
that those who had departed this life
might find pardon for their sins and the
hope of
eternal resurrection.
If you are
searching through your Bible trying to find
II Maccabees, you'd better have a Catholic
Bible. As part of the Apocrypha, it is not
in most Protestant or Jewish Bibles. The
Catholics also use the following passages
from the Bible to support the doctrine of
purgatory, but if you read the passages
carefully, you’ll find the Catholic
interpretations to be a wide stretch of
what is written:
There are several
passages in the New Testament that point to
a process of purification after death.
Thus,
Jesus Christ
declares (Matthew 12:32): "And whosoever
shall speak a word against the Son of man,
it shall be forgiven him: but he that shall
speak against the Holy Ghost, it shall not
be forgiven him, neither in this world, nor
in the world to come." According to St.
Isidore of Seville (Deord. creatur., c.
xiv, n. 6) these words prove that in the
next life "some sins wil be forgiven and
purged away by a certain purifying fire."
St. Augustine also argues "that some
sinners are not forgiven either in this
world or in the next would not be truly
said unless there were other [sinners] who,
though not forgiven in this world, are
forgiven in the world to come" (De Civ.
Dei, XXI, xxiv). The same interpretation is
given by Gregory the Great (Dial., IV,
xxxix); St. Bede (commentary on this text);
St. Bernard (Sermo lxvi in Cantic., n. 11)
and other eminent theological writers.
A further argument is
supplied by St. Paul in I Cor., iii, 11-15:
"For other foundation no man can lay, but
that which is laid; which is
Christ
Jesus. Now
if any man build upon this foundation,
gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay
stubble: Every man's work shall be
manifest; for the day of the Lord shall
declare it, because it shall be revealed in
fire; and the fire shall try every man's
work, of what sort it is. If any man's work
abide, which he hath built thereupon, he
shall receive a reward. If any man's work
burn, he shall suffer loss: but he himself
shall be saved, yet so as by fire." While
this passage presents considerable
difficulty, it is regarded by many of the
Fathers and theologians as evidence for the
existence of an intermediate state in which
the dross of lighter transgressions will be
burnt away, and the soul thus purified will
be saved.
I’ll admit
I’m somewhat at a loss as to how best
address their interpretation of the
scripture above – mostly because I don’t
know what logic they used to twist these
meanings out of those verses. As for the
passage from Paul’s first letter to the
Corinthians, one should back up and start
on verse 10, where Paul says he laid a
foundation as an expert builder, by the
grace God gave him. Gold, silver, and
precious stones represent durable work that
will stand the test of divine judgment.
Wood, hay, or straw denotes worthless work
that will not stand the test, and are
consumed by fire. The work of some
believers will stand the test while that of
others will disappear – emphasizing the
importance of teaching the pure word of
God. As for the last verse that reads that
he shall escape, yet so as by fire. In the
New International Version of the Bible, it
reads, “he himself will be saved, but only
as one escaping through flames.” The best
interpretation indicates that the original
language was a Greek proverbial phrase,
which means, “by a narrow escape”. A
modern equivalent might be, “escaped by the
skin of his teeth”. Paul is really trying
to drive home this point: Okay, so you’ve
been saved. Great. Wonderful. What are
you going to do with this opportunity?
Will you squander it, or will you live a
life in service to your Lord?
One of the
stranger aspects of purgatory is the belief
that one can pray to the souls of loved
ones who are in purgatory, and ask for
intercession. Some believe that the souls
in purgatory can pray for and intercede in
the lives of the living. Here is what the
Catholic Encyclopedia has to say on the matter:
Do the souls in
purgatory pray for us? May we call upon
them in our needs? There is no decision of
the Church on this subject, nor have the
theologians pronounced with definiteness
concerning the invocation of the souls in
purgatory and their intercession for the
living. In the ancient liturgies there are
no prayers of the Church directed to those
who are still in purgatory. On the tombs of
the early Christians nothing is more common
than a prayer or a supplication asking the
departed to intercede with
God for surviving
friends, but these inscriptions seem always
to suppose that the departed one is already
with
God. St. Thomas
(II-II:83:11)
denies that the souls in purgatory pray for
the living, and states they are not in a
position to pray for us, rather we must
make intercession for them. Despite the
authority of St. Thomas, many renowned
theologians hold that the souls in
purgatory really pray for us, and that we
may invoke their aid. Bellarmine (De
Purgatorio, lib. II, xv,) says the reason
alleged by St. Thomas is not at all
convincing, and holds that in virtue of
their greater love of
God and
their union with Him their prayers may have
great intercessory power, for they are
really superior to us in love of
God, and in
intimacy of union with Him. Suarez (De
poenit., disp. xlvii, s. 2, n. 9) goes
farther and asserts "that the souls in
purgatory are holy, are dear to
God, love us with
a true love and are mindful of our wants;
that they know in a general way our
necessities and our dangers, and how great
is our need of Divine help and divine
grace".
When there is
question of invoking the prayers of those
in purgatory, Bellarmine (loc. cit.) says
it is superfluous, ordinarily speaking, for
they are ignorant of our circumstances and
condition. This is at variance with the
opinion of Suarez, who admits knowledge at
least in a general way, also with the
opinions of many modern theologians who
point to the practice now common with
almost all the faithful of addressing their
prayers and petitions for help to those who
are still in a place of purgation. Scavini
(Theol. Moral., XI, n. l74) sees no reason
why the souls detained in purgatory may not
pray for us, even as we pray for one
another. He asserts that this practice has
become common at Rome, and that it has the
great name of St. Alphonsus in its favour.
St. Alphonsus in his work the "Great Means
of Salvation", chap. I, III, 2, after
quoting Sylvius, Gotti, Lessius, and Medina
as favourable to his opinion, concludes:
"so the souls in purgatory, being beloved
by
God and confirmed
in grace, have absolutely no impediment to
prevent them from praying for us. Still the
Church does not invoke them or implore
their intercession, because ordinarily they
have no cognizance of our prayers. But we
may piously believe that
God makes our
prayers known to them". He alleges also the
authority of St. Catharine of Bologna who
"whenever she desired any favour had
recourse to the souls in purgatory, and was
immediately heard".
In summary, the doctrine of purgatory is
unbiblical. Its foundation lies not in
Biblical
scripture, but in Catholic Tradition. The
Apocrypha should not be considered part of
Biblical scripture, and the verses in the
New Testament were twisted to fit an
already established doctrine.
|